A strategic marketing advisor gives you counsel and leaves execution and accountability with you. A fractional CMO owns the marketing plan, leads your team and agencies, and is accountable for pipeline. If you already have a strong marketing leader who wants a sounding board, advice can be enough. If nobody owns the number, you need a fractional CMO.
Key facts
- B2B customers now use an average of ten interaction channels in their buying journey, up from five in 2016, according to McKinsey’s B2B Pulse research. More channels means more decisions that someone has to own, not just discuss.
- The average tenure of a CMO in the S&P 500 is 4.1 years, compared with 5.0 years for all C-suite roles at those companies, per Spencer Stuart. An advisor model depends on a capable in-house leader staying in the seat.
- The Geisheker Group offers Fractional CMO Leadership starting at $10,000 per month with a 90-day minimum, and a one-time Marketing Growth Audit for $10,000.
- Peter Geisheker and Michael Pecora have led 300+ strategy sessions with CEOs.
The real difference: who owns the outcome
Both roles bring senior marketing judgment into your company. The difference is what happens after the meeting ends.
An advisor tells you what they would do. You decide whether to do it, who does it, and how to measure it. If the plan fails, the advisor was still right or wrong in theory. The result belongs to you.
A fractional CMO decides, assigns and follows through. They set the strategy, run the marketing team and the agencies, and report on pipeline to the CEO and the board. If the plan fails, it is their plan that failed. That is the point. You are buying ownership, not opinions.
I have watched many CEOs hire smart advice and get very little from it. The advice was usually good. Nobody inside the company had the time, the authority or the skill to turn it into campaigns, budget shifts and sales handoffs. Good advice that never ships is worth nothing.
If you want the full definition of the fractional role before going further, see what a fractional CMO is and does. This page stays on one question: advice alone, or leadership?
Try two senior CMOs before you hire them
30 minutes with both of us. No hard sell. Written plan in 3 business days.
Side-by-side comparison
| Attribute | Strategic marketing advisor | Fractional CMO |
|---|---|---|
| Role | Outside counselor and sounding board | Member of the leadership team who runs marketing |
| Ownership | Recommends a strategy; you own the plan and its execution | Owns the plan, the budget recommendations and the priorities |
| Accountability | Accountable for the quality of advice | Accountable for pipeline and marketing’s contribution to revenue |
| Involvement | Joins scheduled conversations; works through your leader | Leads the marketing team, directs agencies, sits in leadership and board meetings |
| Team and vendors | Comments on hires and agencies | Hires, manages, coaches, and replaces when needed |
| Best for | Companies with a strong in-house marketing leader who wants an experienced peer | Companies with no senior marketing owner, a stalled pipeline, or a leader who is not working out |
| Main risk | Advice goes unused because no one has authority or capacity to act | Requires the CEO to give real authority, data access and a seat at the table |
The table explains a pattern I see often. A CEO hires an advisor to save money, then quietly becomes the person who has to execute the advice. The CEO’s time is the most expensive resource in the company. Spending it on running marketing is rarely a saving.
When advice alone is enough
Advice can work well. It works when the hard part, ownership, is already covered inside your company. Here is what that looks like:
- You have a capable marketing leader in the seat. A VP or director who already runs the team, manages agencies and reports on pipeline. They want an experienced peer to test ideas against, not a boss.
- Your pipeline is healthy and measured. You know where leads come from, what they cost and how they convert. The question is how to improve, not why nothing is working.
- The decisions are narrow. You need a view on pricing pages, a new segment, or which agency to keep. These are judgment calls your leader can carry out.
- Your leader has the authority to act. They control budget within limits, can change vendors and can push back on sales. Advice lands with someone who can use it.
If all four are true, an outside sounding board can sharpen a team that already works. That is a legitimate need. It is just not the need most growing B2B companies have when they start searching for a “strategic marketing advisor.”
To be clear about our own firm: we lead. If you want an outside diagnosis without an ongoing engagement, the one-time Marketing Growth Audit is the right fit, and it is described below.
When advice is not enough
Most companies that search for a strategic marketing advisor are really describing a leadership gap. Here are the signs that you need someone who owns the outcome:
- Nobody owns the pipeline number. Marketing reports activity (posts, clicks, events). Sales reports deals. No one connects the two.
- The CEO is the de facto CMO. You approve every campaign, mediate between marketing and sales, and review agency invoices. Your time goes to marketing instead of the company.
- You have doers but no director. Coordinators, specialists or agencies execute well, but nobody sets the direction or decides what to stop.
- Spend is rising and results are unclear. You cannot say which channels pay back. The answer to every slow quarter is more budget or a new agency.
- Buyers are harder to reach. With buyers moving across ten channels on average, per McKinsey, coordinating message, channel and sales follow-up is a full leadership job. Recommendations alone do not orchestrate it.
- A growth event is coming. A product launch, new market, funding round or sale process needs a marketing plan that someone is answerable for.
- Your marketing leader left, or is not working out. Turnover in the role is real. Spencer Stuart puts average S&P 500 CMO tenure at 4.1 years, and an advisor cannot fill an empty seat.
In each of these cases, an advisor gives you more good ideas to add to a list that no one is working. A fractional CMO takes the list, cuts it down, assigns it, and reports on results.
Why “consultant” and “fractional CMO” get confused
Part of the confusion is language. “Advisor,” “consultant,” “fractional CMO” and “outsourced CMO” are used loosely, and some people sell advice under a leadership title. If a provider will not lead your team, will not manage agencies, and will not commit to pipeline measures, you are buying advice no matter what the proposal says.
We cover the most common mix-ups, including the idea that a fractional CMO is just a consultant with a new name, in the 15 biggest misconceptions about fractional CMOs.
A simple test helps. Ask any candidate these three questions:
- “Who will you manage on my team and at my agencies, and what decisions can you make without me?”
- “Which pipeline measures will you report to me each month, and what happens if they move the wrong way?”
- “What will exist in 90 days that does not exist today?”
An advisor will answer the first question with “I will work through your people.” A fractional CMO will name the people, the decisions and the measures.
How to decide in five steps
- Name the owner. Write down who, today, is accountable for marketing-sourced pipeline. If the answer is “me” (the CEO) or “no one,” you need leadership, not advice.
- Check your leader’s capacity. If you have a marketing leader, ask whether they are short on ideas or short on authority, time and senior experience. Advice only fixes the first.
- Look at the last year of recommendations. Count how many outside or board recommendations about marketing were fully carried out. A low number tells you execution and ownership are the gap.
- Define the result you need in 90 days. Pipeline targets, a working measurement system, a fixed sales handoff. If the result requires changing what the team does every week, someone has to lead that change.
- Match the model to the gap. Strong owner plus a need for perspective: a sounding board. No owner, unclear numbers or a stalled pipeline: a fractional CMO. Unsure where the problem is: start with an outside diagnosis.
What The Geisheker Group offers
We are two senior B2B fractional CMOs, Peter Geisheker and Michael Pecora. We work with B2B companies with $2M+ in annual revenue and well-funded B2B startups in technology, SaaS, AI and PE-backed businesses. The firm was founded in 1998.
We offer two things, and we state them plainly:
- Fractional CMO Leadership, from $10,000 per month with a 90-day minimum. We own the marketing plan, lead your team and agencies, sit with your leadership team, and are accountable for pipeline. The fee is based on senior experience and outcomes, not time.
- Marketing Growth Audit, a one-time $10,000 engagement for companies that want an outside diagnosis of their marketing, pipeline and measurement before deciding on next steps.
Full details are on our fractional CMO pricing page.
The career results behind the work are Peter’s: 6X inbound lead growth, 100% year-over-year SaaS revenue growth for three consecutive years, a 77% reduction in paid acquisition costs, $50M+ in annual ad spend managed, and programs scaled to deploy up to $1M per week. Those results came from owning plans and budgets, not from offering opinions on them.
Frequently asked questions
Is a strategic marketing advisor cheaper than a fractional CMO?
Sometimes on paper, but the comparison is misleading. With an advisor, someone inside your company still has to own and execute the plan, and that cost is often the CEO’s time. Compare the full cost of getting results, not just the advisor’s invoice.
Can a fractional CMO also act as an advisor to my existing marketing leader?
Yes. When a company has a promising director or VP, a fractional CMO can lead the function while coaching that person to take on more ownership. The difference from pure advice is that the fractional CMO is still accountable for the result while the leader grows.
My board member gives us marketing advice. Is that enough?
It can be helpful perspective, but a board member is an advisor by definition. They will not run your team, manage agencies or report on pipeline monthly. If no one inside the company owns those things, board advice adds to the to-do list without changing results.
How do I know if my problem is strategy or execution?
Look at what happened to the last good idea. If the plan was sound but nothing changed, the gap is ownership and execution. If the team executed well and still missed, the gap is strategy. Most stalled B2B companies have both, which is why a leader who owns strategy and execution together usually helps more than advice alone.
What should an advisor or fractional CMO deliver in the first 90 days?
An advisor delivers recommendations. A fractional CMO should deliver a working plan, clear priorities, a measurement system tied to pipeline, and visible changes in how the team and agencies operate. If you cannot point to what changed, you bought advice.
Talk it through with us
If you are not sure whether you need a sounding board or a leader, that is exactly the question to settle before you spend money. Book a free 30-minute growth plan session on Google Meet with Peter Geisheker and Michael Pecora. You will get a written growth plan within 3 business days, with no hard sell. We hold these sessions for 10 companies a month. Book your growth plan session.
Free Written Growth Plan
Wondering if a fractional CMO is right for you?
Try us before you hire us. Book a free 30-minute working session with both of us and get a written growth plan you can use whether or not you hire us.
Get My Free Growth Plan →No hard sell on the call. Your plan arrives within 3 business days. See a sample plan
